Understanding Comparative Negligence in a Personal Injury Case

Superior Skill, Superior Work Ethic, Superior Results

When you’ve been injured through someone else’s negligence you always have the right to bring a personal injury claim. But that doesn’t mean the defendant’s actions will be the only ones to come under scrutiny.

New York is a comparative negligence state, which means your own actions will also enter into the discussion. Here’s what you need to know about how your own negligence or lack thereof will impact your case.

You can bring the case regardless of your percentage of responsibility.

As to negligence, refer to which states:

“In any action to recover damages for personal injury, injury to property, or wrongful death, the culpable conduct attributable to the claimant or to the decedent, including contributory negligence or assumption of risk, shall not bar recovery, but the amount of damages otherwise recoverable shall be diminished in the proportion which the culpable conduct attributable to the claimant or decedent bears to the culpable conduct which caused the damages.”

In other words, your negligence isn’t even something that gets discussed until the jury is trying to determine the amount of money you will be awarded.

You can still move for summary judgment on the other party’s liability.

Either the plaintiff or the defendant may ask for summary judgment at any time.

In a summary judgment motion, the moving party is asserting that the facts of the case or certain portions of the case are so clear, so obvious, that they don’t really require hours of courtroom time to determine those portions of the case. The ability to ask for a summary judgment saves the court a lot of time and money.

It can also speed up your ability to recover funds. And, of course, it can strengthen your case each time the judge makes a summary judgment in your favor on the matter of any issue.

A recent case that affects how motions for summary judgment are made is the 2018 case Rodriguez v. City of New York New York. In Rodriguez v. The city of New York, the courts ruled that the plaintiff does not bear the burden of establishing the absence of their own comparative negligence in order to obtain summary judgment.

This is important because establishing a defendant’s liability is very important to a personal injury matter. Likewise, as is determining the amount of the damages that should be awarded. If your attorney can obtain summary judgment on your behalf, then you’ve won half the battle before anyone sets foot into a courtroom.

Percentages determine recovery.

There are lots of ways to contribute to your own injury. Perhaps you assumed a risk by taking certain actions. Or you failed to look for a hazard before moving. Or you failed to take a safety precaution you should have taken, such as neglecting to wear a motorcycle helmet or seat belt.

The jury will look at what you did to create the problem, and they will decide what percentage of that action contributed to the end result. For example, they might decide you are 30% responsible for the accident. They would then reduce the award you would have received had you been 0% negligent by 30%.

A personal injury attorney will work to minimize the level of negligence the jury assesses on your behalf so you can maximize your award. Be sure you retain any proof of, or document, anything you did to help minimize your own injuries or risk at the time of the accident.

You should also be careful what you say on social media because this evidence could be used to increase your percentage of contributory negligence.

Taking these steps can make a big difference to you when the case is done.

If you’ve been injured in an accident, call Richman Law Firm PLLC for a free consultation today.

FREE CONSULTATION

Submit this form to have your case reviewed by our attorney.

    Our Practice Areas
    Meet Mr. Richman
    scott-author-min

    SCOTT B. RICHMAN, ESQ.

    Mr. Richman is the Managing Member and Founder of Richman Law Firm PLLC. In his role as Managing Member, Mr. Richman oversees the day-to-day operations of the firm and handles the litigation of the most complex legal matters across a vast array of practice areas and disciplines. ​

    Our Reviews
    Emma Woods
    Emma Woods
    13:13 15 Dec 20
    Scott Richman is a life saver. My husband and I were locked into a lease in a building that seemed pretty okay when we moved in, but we quickly found to be absolutely awful (cockroach infestations, dead mice in the walls, smoking in the lobby of the building, no masks, etc.). Our landlord had taken to just ignoring our calls and emails asking to break our lease. They decided we could break it for a 3 month penalty, which is NOT realistic or okay. Scott got her attention, and got us out of the lease in return for us allowing them to keep our security deposit. He saved us a ton of money, and did it SO fast - I think the entire process was about a week in total. Scott knows what he's doing, and he's a great person to have in your corner when you're in a tough spot! Thanks again Scott!
    Leisha Majtan
    Leisha Majtan
    17:59 05 Dec 20
    I had never worked with a law firm in the past and was always hesitant to do so. But Scott Richman came highly recommended to assist with an accident I had back in July of 2020 and I must say his professionalism and diligence with my case was outstanding. He explained the process thoroughly and answered all questions expertly. I would not hesitate to use him again.
    Sean Ajifowobaje
    Sean Ajifowobaje
    01:00 24 Nov 20
    Scott did an awesome job handling the renegotiation of my non-compete agreement. He was straight forward, timely and professional. I would recommend him to anyone in regard with dealing with contract agreements.
    Dale Farquharson
    Dale Farquharson
    13:31 20 Nov 20
    Scott is very informative very professional and works hard on settling your case in a fast efficient way.
    Paul Berge
    Paul Berge
    17:20 11 Sep 20
    Scott Richman was hands down the best attorney we have ever had. He helped our company solve a tricky and challenging problem with speed, efficiency and professionalism. His knowledge and attention to detail go well beyond this 5 star rating. He is exceptional at what he does and I would highly recommend him.
    Yasir Sitara
    Yasir Sitara
    21:53 07 Aug 20
    I came to Scott looking for help in reviewing my film contract, and I got exactly what I was looking for and then some! His communication, diligence, and knowledge of all things pertaining to the law is second to none.. and he adds a light touch of humor along the way. Scott Richman is a man of class and i would highly recommend him to anyone reading this, you will not be sorry!
    Studio Opening
    Studio Opening
    09:42 27 Jul 20
    In handling my matters Scott Richman was friendly, competent, timely, reliable, and above all, gave sound legal advice.
    Brendan Bertoli
    Brendan Bertoli
    16:37 29 Jun 20
    Srdana Pokrajac
    Srdana Pokrajac
    19:14 09 Jun 20
    Scott was very reassuring, responsive and addressed my real estate concerns promptly. I highly recommend his services and would hire Scott again.
    Robert Rosenfeld
    Robert Rosenfeld
    17:59 27 Apr 20
    As an attorney myself I appreciated Scott’s diligence, enthusiasm and communication. We finally got the primary carrier to put up its policy limits so that an underinsurance arbitration can be demanded. I’m confident that Scott will continue to fight to maximize my recovery.
    Mindy Jezierski
    Mindy Jezierski
    17:01 30 Mar 20
    I was highly recommended to Mr. Scott Richman through a family member of mine. Mr Richman was very professional and attentive to our situation. He walked us through the whole process of what to expect as we were looking to be compensated for our daughter’s injury due to a car accident that she was involved in. His time and attention to our case left a positive impression on us. He answered all our questions, emails and phone calls in a speedily manner. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone else that is looking for a caring and attention to detail lawyer such as him.
    Aaron Silbert
    Aaron Silbert
    20:45 17 Jan 20
    In a pinch, I needed general legal services within 24 hours. After a quick search, I found Scott and his firm and gave them a call. Scott answered the phone, took the time to walk me through what was happening and what I needed done, and then went out of his way to make sure it was taken care of that day. He even met me after business hours to ensure everything was taken care of, even printing out extra copies of everything to make sure I had one on file. I highly recommend Scott and his team for any of your legal needs - he is fantastic!
    Sasha Roudenko
    Sasha Roudenko
    15:31 15 Oct 19
    Scott Richman took a painful and unpleasant experience and helped me navigate it while always being available to answer any questions or address any concerns whether it was via email or phone. He always took the time to explain everything including any areas of confusion without making me feel stupid or small. He was always respectful, very knowledgeable, and worked so hard on my case. I cannot recommend him highly enough for any legal needs you may have.
    Erica Carter
    Erica Carter
    21:12 12 Sep 19
    Scott Richman handled my case with the utmost care, respect, and expediently. I had a civil matter that he resolved for me, and leaving this matter in his hands was the best thing I could have done. He communicates effectively and often, and ensures that as his client you are never in the dark. Very grateful for his services and give him my highest recommendation.
    Michael Feinberg
    Michael Feinberg
    15:04 08 Aug 19
    Scott Richman is an extremely honest and professional attorney who helped settle my personal injury claim. His work is thorough and reliable. Additionally, Scott makes himself available for his clients and truly focuses on making sure that his clients needs are timely met.
    Kristen Epifania
    Kristen Epifania
    20:31 31 Jul 19
    Mr. Richman is a respected colleague with impressive experience in civil litigation. I have seen his work firsthand and he is a powerful advocate and extremely knowledgable in his field. I would trust him to handle my own matter and recommend him to anyone in need of a civil attorney.
    Mehdi Essmidi
    Mehdi Essmidi
    20:45 25 Jul 19
    Mr. Richman is one of the most capable civil litigators I have met. He conducts his practice fairly and ethically at all times. He always approaches each case with several strategies, he has no problem standing up for his client’s interests, and he uses his talent for quick thinking to resolve issues for his clients very efficiently. I have referred several clients to his firm because I trust that he will do excellent work for anyone that retains his services. I endorse this lawyer.
    Robert Golden
    Robert Golden
    20:22 24 Jun 19
    Mr. Richman did a wonderful job handling an estate issue for me and my family. It was frustrating at times do to attorney’s on the other side, but he persisted in a very professional manner and got the job done. Thank you.
    KayBienne Rosado
    KayBienne Rosado
    16:14 24 Jun 19
    Richman Law Firm PLLC is an amazing firm and worth working perusing is you need a lawyer. Scott Richman works hard and took care of everything quickly. He was easy to get a hold of, answering emails and phone calls immediately almost every time. He settled my case within a little over 8 weeks. He was in constant contact, keeping me up to date on the progress of my case. After settling my case, he reached out often to be sure I received my check and to confirm that all looked as promised per our contract. He answered every question, never making me feel stupid or small. He is a great guy to work with, very nice and very professional. Hire this firm, you won’t regret it.
    Adam Hersh
    Adam Hersh
    17:17 21 Feb 19
    I strongly endorse Scott. I have known Scott for years. I am an attorney in Florida, and whenever I have a client who needs legal representation in New York, my immediate thought is to call Scott. I have worked on several matters with Scott, and I am very impressed with his excellent work ethic and strong attention to detail.Scott makes sure to focus on the right issues to get the best outcomes for his clients.I strongly recommend Scott for those in need of a strong, aggressive attorney in New York.
    Next Reviews